Overview of cots software component evaluation cots research for development of cotsbased software system cots. A complexity of cots selection processes has great impact on the cots method development, information tools and frameworks in consequence. The dos and donts of software selection and evaluation. An elite model for cots component selection process. Methods for measurementbased cots assessments and selection. This 2004 report focuses on cots product evaluations conducted for the purpose of. The cots application evaluation scorecard gives clear insight into the capabilities of each software component and how it stacks up to what a client wishes to achieve. Institute, carnegie mellon university, pennsylvania, united states. Using software process modeling to analyze the cots based. Unconstrained iris acquisition and recognition using cots. Pdf commercial off the shelf software can save development time and money if you can find a. Evaluation and selection cots software cots software evaluation and selection process is the most important process in the cbsd. How we measure reads a read is counted each time someone views a publication. Each rfp template master, and its matching software selection toolkit, can help you reduce research time, eliminate timeconsuming data entry, and make more accurate decisions during each software selection step, as.
Given the immature state of the art, in the literature the term cots can mean. Determine what is necessary to fulfill project goals. An alternative methodology is one in which the cots software selection and evaluation influences and is conducted concurrently with the requirement definition process. By using gpse system, the user can follow the mwaf process and design the architecture which best describes the given evaluation problem. As part of a cooperative effort, the software engineering institute and national research council canada have defined a tailorable commercial offtheshelf cots software product evaluation process. Software evaluation guide software sustainability institute. The state will not issue a notice to proceed to the contractor for the purchase and delivery of the cots hris software until the state awards. Therefore many models have been proposed to handle the cots software evaluation and selection problems, but all of these models have a lack to be accepted and considered as formal method for evaluating and. In particular, the use of commercial offtheshelf cots products as elements of larger systems is becoming increasingly commonplace, due to shrinking budgets. Our requirementsdriven cots product evaluation process rcpep ensures a quality outcome. Fleet system software evaluation and selection rfp. Requirementsdriven cots product evaluation process, 2001 21, cre cotsbased.
This approach has advantages in terms of cost and time because it results in a more directed. The sta te of the art, authorferas tarawneh and jamaiah hj. A process for cots software product evaluation carnegie mellon. The general statements of an ontology project and construction were presented as well.
In otso method, the evaluation criteria are gradually defined as selection process progresses. A related term, milcots, refers to cots products for use by the u. State of art and practice of cots components search engines ieee. As cots are identified, the evaluation and selection processes begin. This framework will fill the gap between stateof art and stateofpractice and reduce the incredulous problems in current cots selection methods. It also takes into account ease of use, training time and upkeep criteria as well as a clear breakdown of the software s coding and architecture. Therefore, evaluating and selecting appropriate cots product is one of the most critical activities in cotsbased system development. A formal process for evaluating cots software products. The present methods for single cots seleetion do not fit multiple cots seleetion very well.
Yahaya faudziah ahmad fauziah baharom in the recent years. Commercial offtheshelf or commercially available offtheshelf cots products are packaged solutions which are then adapted to satisfy the needs of the purchasing organization, rather than the commissioning of custommade, or bespoke, solutions. An elite model for cots component selection process asif irshad khan department of computer science, fcit. Yahaya faudziah ahmad fauziah baharom, year2011 feras tarawneh, jamaiah hj. The evaluation criteria are derived from reuse goals and factors that influence these goals 4. Multiple cots selection process based on extension to fcd. This process begins with planning for an evaluation and selection cots software. Cots software evaluation, socialtechnical evaluation criteria, customer participation 1 introduction cots software component selection is a process of determining fitness for use of. The process of cots commercial offtheshelf software selection is difficult due to the large number of existing cots components. Performed right after the requirements analysis, this process provides the evaluators with more concise, structural, and stepbystep activities for determining the best cots software product with manageable risk. These solutions, we believe, extend state of the art requirements acquisition techniques to the. Citeseerx a general purpose software evaluation system. There are similarities between evaluating and selecting an erp system for use by an. Unfortunately, many methods that have been proposed in previous studies for evaluating and selecting cots software are still have many limitations and lack to apply and accept as a formal method in the industry.
The major steps required to accurately select a new software system are described below. Dotfaaar112 handbook for the selection and evaluation. The background fundamentals for that evaluation process, as well as steps and techniques to follow, are described in this report. In the recent years, the commercial offtheshelf cots products are being increasingly used in the world of software development. As part of a cooperative effort, the software engineering institute sei. Software developers face the challenge of developing intime, low cost, high profit and highquality software to meet competitive requirements and user demands. The increased use of cots software in organizations of any size makes evaluation and selection of an appropriate product an essential activity, safrinko said. An effective software product evaluation uses a formal process commensurate with the investment required for product acquisition and support to assess product quality and suitability prior to purchase. General purpose software evaluation gpse system uses state of the art statistical methods based on multidimensional weighted attribute framework mwaf for the evaluation of the available alternatives.
Systematic construction of goaloriented cots taxonomies. Software soar or software assurance soar its full title is stateofthe art resources soar for software vulnerability detection, test, and evaluation. A formal process for evaluating cots software products a s government agencies and businesses become more dependent on commercial offtheshelf cots software products to automate tasks, the ability to determine product quality and suitability has become increasingly important. Selecting cots software components to fit requirements is still a problem. In large software system, eomponents depend on eaeh other, whieh leads to the difficult evaluation of individual eomponent.
This stateofthe art paper has as its charge the following. System selection steps rfp software software evaluation. Decide if the services of a contractor are necessary and carefully plan how to monitor, set the standards. Ontologies supporting the process of selection and. This paper models the cots evaluation problem as an mcdm problem and proposes a fivephase cots selection model, combining the technique of analytic network process anp and modified topsis. Commercial offtheshelf cots, matrix method, selection criteria, cbse abstract. The stateofthe art resource for software vulnerability detection, test, and evaluation, a. Some of the most common cots evaluation mistakes include. However, many organizations struggle in their attempts to select an appropriate product for use in systems. A theoretical study on component selection and certification. This paper describes a systematic process for decision support in evaluating and ranking cots software. Some methods have been proposed in the last years for dealing with cots selection. The state of the art, author feras tarawneh and jamaiah hj.
Stateofthe art resources soar for software vulnerability detection, test, and evaluation gregory larsen, task leader e. The first phase cots assessment and selection is the most crucial phase in. Airborne electronic hardware aeh includes modern stateofthe art and highly integrated cots microprocessors that. Through the master contracts awarded as a result of this solicitation, the state will have a flexible means of obtaining these. Because deeloping highquality software is a complex and. The evaluation criteria definition process in otso essentially decomposes the requirements for the cots software into a hierarchical. A process for cots software product evaluation july 2004 technical report santiago comelladorda, john dean, grace lewis, edwin j.
Therefore, evaluating and selecting appropriate cots product is one of the most critical activities in cotsbased. The software components for the same can be selected either from the available commercialofftheshelf repository or developed inhouse. One approach is to assemble a software selection team with representatives who can advocate for the needs of their individual areas. Cotsbased software development has emerged as an approach aiming to. In this paper, we propose a data envelopment analysis dea based nonlinear multiobjective. But a major issue arises when the right individuals are not involved in the evaluation process. Cotsbased systems cbs development is a process of building systems. Preliminary results of a stateofthepractice survey on motivations of using. The general aim of this paper is to present ontologies supporting cots components selection and evaluation process. However, many organizations struggle in their attempts to select appropriate software products for use in systems. The rfp for these services will be released after the cots hris software application has been selected and a contract award has been made and approved by the board of public works. Especially in smaller organizations, one person may be tasked. This readytouse rfp master template queries vendors about more than 1,700 stateofthe art criteria essential to the successful evaluation, selection, and implementation of an integrated fleet management software. Mcdm based evaluation and ranking of commercial offthe.
Selection of a wrong software package can turn out to be costly and adversely affect business processes. Look at commercial offthe shelf cots and government offtheshelf gots products and evaluate them carefully see 5 fah5 exhibit h217. A process for cots software product evaluation springerlink. Evaluating and selecting software packages that meet an organizations requirements is a difficult software engineering process. The size and the complexity of the software increases with a corresponding increase in its functionality, hence leads to the development of the modular software. The report presents the current stateofthe art, a research design, and then presents the.
In todays scenario, software has become an essential component in all kinds of systems. The government of the united states has a royaltyfree governmentpurpose. It presents a state of the art and practice of search engines followed by a study. While perhaps ideal, not every company will be in a position to do this. They propose a requirementsbased cots product evaluation process, rcpep, that. Abstract this document presents the state of the art related with the systematic construction and analysis of i models for assessing cotsbased systems development. Identify the processes which support cots software evaluation and selection. Since the commercial offtheshelf cots software become widespread components in the market for building the systems with less time and cost, the cots evaluation and selection becomes a nontrivial continue reading. Source selection advisory council ssac is a group of individuals, appointed as needed by the ssa, that provides counsel during the source selection process, prepares the comparative analysis of the ssebs final evaluation results, and makes an award recommendation to the ssa.
Anything less can only serve to justify a predetermined choice. Cots selection attributes that used during evaluation and selection process. The aim of this paper is to provide a basis to improve the process of evaluation and selection of the software. It also benefits and risks of using cots components will be used for building framework for evaluation and selection cots.
For systems that depend on cots products, the evaluation and selection of ap. Then a multiple cots seleetion process was proposed based on extension of a proven system deeomposition teehnique named fcd. The anp method is used in obtaining the relative weights of criteria but not the entire evaluation process to reduce the large number of pairwise comparison. Social technical approach to cots software evaluation. The state of the art feras tarawneh1, fauziah baharom2, jamaiah hj. Thus the whole steps of the ontology construction process for cots were described in details. The software soar was originally released to the public in 2014 wheeler2014, and an updated version is now available wheeler2016. The current stateoftheart in decision support takes the intelligence.
Mjud cots commercial offtheshelf software 6 p a g e k180002 25l section 1 general information 1. Companies that do not have resources with the right skills to facilitate software evaluation and selection should hire a professional with these skills. The software assurance stateoftheart resource csiac. Background the purpose of the proposal evaluation process is to provide a mechanism to determine which. Dean of awang had salleh graduate school of arts and sciences. Cots evaluation using modified topsis and anp sciencedirect. While software selection made simple is unrealistic, companies should take an objective, balanced approach to make the process easier. Use your best judgement in selecting these, bearing in mind that the goal is to produce valuable information on the state of the software package. The fist section presents an overview of the componentbased systems cbs development processes. The growing use of commercial products in large systems makes evaluation and selection of appropriate products an increasingly essential activity.
294 545 789 255 365 1168 971 1470 992 632 1490 981 376 139 693 371 537 1145 569 493 79 842 1516 516 1046 1456 616 612 1395 1419 623 336 423 320 681 639 1267 556 1229 290 1225